Umbrella companies are businesses that act as employers for temporary workers, such as contractors and freelancers. They are often used by recruitment agencies to pay workers through PAYE, which means they deduct tax and National Insurance contributions from their wages.
However, not all umbrella companies are compliant with the law and some may use unethical or illegal practices to reduce their tax liabilities or exploit workers. For example, some umbrella companies may:
- Charge workers hidden fees or costs that are not clearly explained or agreed upon
- Fail to provide workers with payslips or accurate information about their pay and deductions
- Use loan schemes or offshore arrangements to pay workers less than the minimum wage or avoid paying tax and National Insurance
- Misclassify workers as self-employed or outside IR35 when they are actually employed or inside IR35
- Deny workers their statutory rights and benefits, such as holiday pay, sick pay, maternity pay, pension contributions, etc.
These practices can have serious consequences for workers, such as:
- Losing out on income and paying more tax than they should
- Facing unexpected tax bills or penalties from HMRC
- Having no legal protection or recourse if they are mistreated or underpaid
- Being exposed to financial risks and liabilities if the umbrella company goes bust or is investigated by HMRC
The government has recognised the problem of non-compliant umbrella companies and has taken some steps to tackle them. For example, it has:
- Introduced new legislation in April 2021 to require recruitment agencies to provide workers with a key information document that outlines their pay rate, deductions, fees, and employment status before they start work
- Launched a consultation in July 2021 to explore how to regulate umbrella companies and ensure they meet their legal obligations to workers and HMRC
- Set up a dedicated team within HMRC to investigate and prosecute cases of tax evasion and fraud involving umbrella companies
- Published guidance on its website to help workers understand how umbrella companies work and what to look out for when choosing one
These measures are welcome but may not be enough to protect workers from unscrupulous umbrella companies. Therefore, some experts and campaigners have called for more radical reforms, such as:
- Banning agencies and employers from forcing workers to use umbrella companies or restricting their choice of umbrella companies
- Creating a single enforcement body that can oversee and regulate all aspects of umbrella company compliance
- Introducing a statutory definition of an umbrella company and a code of conduct that sets out minimum standards of transparency, accountability, and fairness
- Establishing a public register of compliant umbrella companies that workers can check before signing up with one
These reforms could help create a level playing field for umbrella companies and ensure that workers are treated fairly and paid correctly. They could also benefit the government by increasing tax revenues and reducing tax avoidance.
Umbrella companies can play a useful role in the UK's flexible labour market, but they need to be regulated and monitored effectively. The government should act swiftly and decisively to crack down on non-compliant umbrella companies and protect the rights and interests of temporary workers.
If you need any help with Umbrella companies, IR35 or anything else contractor related give us a call or drop us a line at WarwickHR
View more of our
A new legal challenge could expose UK employers to the risk of being sued for tax evasion by umbrella companies